Car damage guide · Should I repair it?
Insurance Claim or Pay for a Scratch Repair?
For small scratches and scuffs, many owners compare the repair price with their insurance excess and the possible effect on their no-claims discount before deciding whether to claim. Every policy is different, so check your own policy wording or speak to your insurer before you decide.
The main things to weigh up
This is general information, not financial or insurance advice. Your insurer is the only one who can tell you how your policy works.
Most people look at three things:
- the excess you would pay on a claim
- the possible effect on your no-claims discount and future premiums
- what your policy wording actually covers
Having a fixed repair price to compare against makes this much easier.
Your excess
The excess is the amount you pay towards a claim yourself. Many policies have a compulsory excess and a voluntary excess on top, and the two are added together.
If the cost of a repair is close to or below your excess, a claim may not leave you better off. Our guide price is from £150 per panel, with the fixed price coming from your photos. The car scratch repair cost guide and bumper scuff repair cost guide show what affects the price.
Your no-claims discount
A no-claims discount (sometimes called a no-claims bonus) rewards years without a claim. Depending on your policy, making a claim may reduce it unless it is protected, and even protected discounts can have conditions.
A claim may also need to be declared when you get future quotes. Ask your insurer how a claim for cosmetic damage would be treated on your policy.
Policy wording differs
Cover for scratches and vandalism is not the same across policies. Some points to look for in your documents:
- whether accidental damage and malicious damage are covered
- whether a different excess applies to vandalism
- whether the insurer uses its own approved repairers
- whether a claim affects your no-claims discount when you were not at fault
If anything is unclear, check with your insurer before you book any repair.
If the damage was deliberate
A key scratch or other vandalism is deliberate damage, and some owners choose to report it to the police. If you are thinking of claiming, your insurer may ask whether it has been reported, so check what they need.
Take clear photos and note the date and place before anything is repaired. Those photos are also what we need for a quote.
When paying for the repair yourself suits
Many owners pay privately for small, cosmetic damage such as a single scratch, a scuffed bumper corner or a small dent. A mobile repair at home or work, usually done in a few hours, can be simpler than going through a claim.
Our key scratch repair service and scuffed bumper repair cover most of this kind of damage.
When the damage is more than cosmetic
SMART repair is not for split or badly cracked bumpers, panels pushed out of line or crash damage. That kind of damage often goes through a bodyshop for a respray or new parts, and an insurance claim is more common. We'll tell you from your photos if it needs a bodyshop. See our SMART repair vs bodyshop guide.
Common questions
Can I get a quote from you before I contact my insurer?
Yes. Send us your photos and we will give you a fixed price, usually the same day. You can then compare it with your excess and policy terms.
Can you do a repair that my insurer is paying for?
Some insurers use their own approved repairers, so check with your insurer first. We take payment from you directly, with a deposit to secure the booking and the balance once the job is finished.
Do I have to tell my insurer about a scratch I pay for myself?
Policies differ on what you must tell your insurer and when. Check your policy wording or ask your insurer directly.
Related repairs and guides
- Car scratch repair cost guide
- Key scratch repair service
- Key scratch repair
- Can key scratches be repaired?
- SMART repair vs touch-up pen
- Is it worth fixing scratches before selling?
- Glossary: Key scratch
- Glossary: Scuff
- Glossary: Respray
- Repair cost estimator: get a guide price
- Areas we cover for mobile SMART repair
- Back to the car damage guide
Get a fixed price for your repair
Send a couple of photos, one close up and one from further back, and we'll reply with a fixed price, usually the same day. You're under no obligation to book.
Get my free quoteOr call 07784 628096 · WhatsApp us